There has been much talk of needing new democratic institutions for electors and their representatives to enhance democracy and re-focus everyone onto the perennial challenges of reconciling personal and sectional interests with the common good, technological change and respect for nature.
It’s been said a thousand times about politics: Oh, they are all the same – only in it for themselves – only appear when they want your vote; and so on and on. Democratic politics, as now practiced in England, has become reduced to a dialogue of mutual incomprehension. Not because of anyone’s individual moral or intellectual deficiency, the deficit is institutional. Our current framework of democratic politics has not been developed in line with the capabilities of citizens and politicians alike, resulting in the latter feeling reviled and unwanted and the former feeling manipulated or patronised. Trust is lost because policy rivalry has been pushed aside by competition for votes – forgetting that the ballot confers legitimacy but does not bestow wisdom.
Are there practical measures which might be taken to augment present practices in order to remedy this worrying situation? How might citizens to be enabled to play a responsible part in ways beyond those presently open to them, without feeling overburdened? What innovations might extend the familiar democratic process for everyone whilst not in any way being a substitute? Representatives elected to public office must still remain responsible and accountable for deciding and overseeing public policy.
The problem with Westminster
Almost a century has passed since universal suffrage was adopted in the UK. Citizens currently have no greater role to play in governance than the one they had when most women won the vote in 1918; despite secondary education for all (1945) most school-leavers moving into tertiary education, mass communication by radio (1920s) television (1950s) and now the arrival of the digital age. Yet citizens-at-large are treated as if they have no capacity or desire to have a view, while having to navigate their way through propaganda, dubious ‘consultations’ and general/ubiquitous/constant on-line mischief. Evidence from their experience is presently too easily ignored with impunity (like happened with the Post Office scandal).
At present the Westminster system of politics, governance and law is dominated by adversarial processes. We need a counterbalancing element to be introduced. This means developing practices that ensure that all relevant views, knowledge and questions are sourced from, and made available to, all citizens who might be affected (in a non-partisan way). It means creating ‘knowledge-in-common’ before considering what might be done: a mutually informative, educative and political purpose not beholden to mass or social media.
The solution could be constituency trusts
Experience has taught us that citizens best assert their power by way of representation in an elected assembly chosen through a robust and respected system of voting. Any additional system aimed at enabling citizens to contribute their influence between elections must be designed to be compatible with this. To gain popular acceptance, new methods would work best if managed ‘locally’ – at a level seen by citizens as appropriate to their sense of locality and meaningful reciprocal obligations – while being at a scale that attracts assistance from advisors and journalists, and to justify the resources needed.
As parliamentary representation is currently organised by way of constituencies it would be logical to organise influential activity likewise, with the direct involvement of current and aspiring parliamentary and local government representatives on a fully cross-party (and non) basis. Parliamentary constituencies, as the constitutionally-primary point of contact between individuals and government, would thus seem to be the natural place to institute a new democratic facility. I would call them constituency trusts.
Once established, constituency trusts would also be available for interaction with the prevailing and any future local/regional/devolved systems of governance, as well as for locally defined communal purposes. There are numerous off- and on-line participative techniques now being used and evaluated worldwide for each prospective trust to draw upon and adapt to their local purpose. There may well be a role for an enhanced social education sector here. However, merely grafting new techniques onto the existing, underdeveloped democratic system will not suffice.
How trusts could work
Constituencies vary widely in their geographical, social, local-governmental and political characteristics but this is not call a for constituency trusts to be identical, provided they are designed (and maintained) to common core principles and standards. They must:
- Involve all political parties active (according to an agreed criterion) in the constituency
- Be confined to, yet include in its activities as of right, all persons on an up-to-date electoral register of the constituency
- Enable national and local politicians (and their advisors) to better gauge comprehension and mood amongst the electorate
- Ensure deliberations are held accountable to evidence, expose misinformation and challenge propaganda from vested interests
- Have a not-for-profit legal status
- Be proofed against takeover by factions or obsessives, and extraction of data for profit
- Uphold public-service standards of civility, and have processes to deal with defamatory or otherwise offensive statements or material
- Make provision for contributions to its activities by way of all channels: electronic and otherwise
- Be found rewarding by the executives who organise its activities, knowing they are part of the democratic process.
Establishing and subsequently governing a trust should be in the hands of its own stewards. These would be one or two persons nominated and confirmed annually by each political party that received a significant vote at the most recent election, together with a similar number of non-aligned constituency electors selected for a set period.
The stewards would be accountable under the law for the conduct and assets of the trust and would appoint and oversee executives to organise the trust’s public activities. Stewards would be local party staff and not get extra remuneration for their role.
The executives would be local persons who would undertake not to take part in trust activities on their own account and while serving, they would together form a public service body that is not affiliated to one specific party but is a cooperative of all parties voted into parliament by that electorate. Such persons might be drawn from local party activists and others who are keen to develop their understanding and capabilities in the political sphere. In this way, constituency trusts could perform an additional educational role and might also help develop able future candidates for public office.
Going forward:
This reform of the democratic practice does not need prior legislation or top-down exhortation but rather local educational initiatives; practice through which experience, and expertise, can be nurtured. Nor does it inhibit discussion about reform of other aspects of democratic practice; indeed, it would facilitate it.
Constituency trusts would bring local parties and politicians, their policies and their actions face-to-face with each other in front of, and with the involvement of, their constituents. They would all scrutinise, challenge and otherwise police each other’s claims and statements in plain sight on an ongoing basis, not merely at election time.
Constituency trusts could well be the next step on the long journey of understanding how to bring the public fully into democracy.
To contact the author with questions or suggestions about his idea, please use email: constituencytrusts@btinternet.com
Editorial: This opinion article by Cliff Pelham suggests constituency trusts as a new way we could reform constituency politics across the UK. It is a novel idea that the author hopes may increase interest in, knowledge of, and the quality of politics. If any readers have suggestions for how such a change could be refined or improved, we invite them to contact either the author or Bylines with their own article.







