Editor addition: The play ‘They don’t really care about us’ will be performed at the Liverpool Fringe in October 2024, before going on tour
Liverpool Hope Street Theatre’s latest show, They Don’t Really Care About Us, opened for the second of three nights on Friday 31st May. The whodunit drama, co-written by Rachel Louise Clark, Sab Muthusamy of 4am Productions, and co-directed by Rachel, Sab and George Fragakis, is a searing and gritty story of race, gender and crime, set against the backdrop of 1990s Liverpool.
The opening act was powerful and intense
The show opened with a full ensemble performance; a sophisticated and meticulously crafted piece of physical theatre, to the soundtrack of one of Michael Jackson’s most powerful and iconic songs, from which the play gets its namesake. The opening performance’s coordinated movements served as an expository experience that introduced the audience to the setting, as well as to the mighty ten-person cast – think if HBO wrote the opening credits for theatre productions. Hardened expressions and pounding fists set the tone for the rest of the show – this was going to be intense.
Racial tension and injustices
The story is set in the mid-late 1990s, against a backdrop of racial tension. We see this with the lead character, Dinesh, played by co-writer/co-director Sab, who’s no stranger to frequent racially-motivated injustices, micro-agressions and unfair judgements. There’s no denying that this is a bold show, but that doesn’t mean that subtleties aren’t evident. The audience is introduced (or for those lucky enough to have been there, were reminded of) the 1990s through a lens of references like ‘Stephen Lawrence who got killed a few years ago’ and visual clues, such as characters walking around with a Walkman player, rifling through CD collections of, you guessed it, Michael Jackson, but also the likes of the Pixies’ classic ‘Where is My Mind?’ – a song that becomes an unexpected but important soundtrack to the action..

Complex relationships and scouse humour
We’re first introduced to Vanessa Campbell, played by Nina Price, who’s back home in Liverpool to celebrate the release of her debut poetry book, which is flying off the shelves. Her two oldest friends, George, played by the effervescent Paul Ryan, and Dinesh, are Vanessa’s biggest fans. George in particular, the comedic relief in the show, is practically feverish about not just Vanessa’s rise to fame, but also about the poet herself, this despite being in a serious relationship with girlfriend Sarah, played by Madeleine Lloyd Jones, who is less than impressed by his friendship with Vanessa. Dinesh also admires Vanessa, but presents as much more level headed, even if he can’t seem to escape his history of violent blackouts, triggered by racist harassment and bullying in his youth. Is all this foreshadowing the plot reveal, or a significant plot device, designed to throw us off the scent? Finding out is all part of the fun.
The character of George packs a punch of humour, but just wait until you’re introduced to Vanessa’s family. Mum and dad, Carol and Graham, played by Lisa Mogan and Alan Kenny, bounce off each other with an authenticity only native scousers can fully appreciate. But it is sister Caitlyn, played by actor Abi Tyrer, ably assisted by Rachel and Sab’s fantastic script, who has the audience in stitches with her irreverent lines. She translates hard faced teen scouseness with maximum relatability and authenticity.
The murder scene and the use of lights is striking
Characters and motives suitably developed, not to mention a potential stalker on the loose, it’s time for a murder. It’s no secret that at the end of the first act, Vanessa is brutally bottled and killed at the end of an evening of the friendship group drinking together. This is where the pace really picks up, not just through the violent twist in the tale, but in the way it’s illustrated. This has to be seen to be fully appreciated – simple props and intelligent use of lighting make the kill scene the most striking act in the whole play. It is arguably one of those highly anticipated moments in theatre that takes a play from good to better than great.

A masterful whodunit
What ensues is a masterful whodunit, with outstanding portrayals from actors Hannah Kidman and Kru Lundy who play the clashing detective duo, DCI Hannah Brindle and DCI Josh Miller, tasked with finding the killer. Kru has possibly the most difficult job, playing a prejudiced police officer, as well as an outright fascist jailmate to Dinesh, as he awaits his day in court. This is seconded by Phil Halfpenny’s unenviable role as Edward ‘The Bastard’ Manson, a cutthroat prosecution lawyer who’ll happily pull the race card to get their way in court. Thank goodness for characters like Sefor, played by Leonisha Barley, Dinesh’s lawyer, who, driven by her own experience with racism, fights tooth and nail for Dinesh in court. The characters propel the state of affairs in society around race and gender into the minds of the audience. We’re subjected to watching injustice after injustice handed out to the marginalised within the story, including Dinesh’s mum, Geeta, played by Sudha Rajavelu in her first ever stage role, who, after already having lost her husband, fears her brown-skinned son even leaving the house to confront the world outside.
You won’t be able to guess the outcome
The mastery of the script is illustrated by the fact that any one of the main characters could be placed as the killer. There isn’t a single weak link to this production, as we’re taken on a meandering journey into the minds of each and every character, including Vanessa in the afterlife. Take it from me, you’ll never guess who did it, and as soon as you’ve settled on a name, the twists just keep coming. It ends almost as quickly as it starts but without a doubt leaves you wanting more.
The show finished its run on Saturday 1st June but if the audience‘s standing ovation has anything to say about it, it won’t be the last time it’s put on stage.
Find out more about the writers, directors and production company, 4am, on their Instagram profiles:
- Rachel Louise-Clark – co-director and co-writer: @rachellouiseclark_01
- Sab Muthusamy – co-director, co-writer and actor: @sabmuthusamy
- George Fragakis – co-director @giorgos.fragakis
- 4am Productions – @4amproductionsam

CLICK HERE TO DONATE TO OUR CROWDFUNDER
HELP US BECOME STRONGER SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO DELIVER POWERFUL CITIZEN JOURNALISM!








