• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9755
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
North West Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
    • Crime and Justice
    • Education
    • Equality
    • Health
    • Migration
    • War
    • World
  • Environment
    • Nature and Wildlife
    • Pollution
  • Politics
    • Brexit
    • Economy
  • Lifestyle
    • Art, Craft and Photography
    • Cartoon
    • Books
    • Culture, Language and Religion
    • Dance
    • Food and Drink
    • History
    • Human Interest
    • Music
    • Sport
    • TV, Film and Theatre
  • Business
    • Local Business
    • Technology
    • Trade
    • Transport
  • Region
    • Cheshire
    • Cumbria
    • Greater Manchester
    • Lancashire
    • Liverpool and Merseyside
    • Local Councils and Elections
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Crime and Justice
    • Education
    • Equality
    • Health
    • Migration
    • War
    • World
  • Environment
    • Nature and Wildlife
    • Pollution
  • Politics
    • Brexit
    • Economy
  • Lifestyle
    • Art, Craft and Photography
    • Cartoon
    • Books
    • Culture, Language and Religion
    • Dance
    • Food and Drink
    • History
    • Human Interest
    • Music
    • Sport
    • TV, Film and Theatre
  • Business
    • Local Business
    • Technology
    • Trade
    • Transport
  • Region
    • Cheshire
    • Cumbria
    • Greater Manchester
    • Lancashire
    • Liverpool and Merseyside
    • Local Councils and Elections
No Result
View All Result
North West Bylines
Home News Equality

Trans or not, women are women

Swim England refuse to update a female swimmer's sex marker, even though evidence shows trans women do not have an advantage over cis women

Sophie Molly by Sophie Molly
13-03-2026 13:45
in Equality, Opinion Corner, Sport
Reading Time: 8 mins read
A A
Swimming pool with ropes to mark the lanes

image by Serena Repice Lentini. Free to use under the Unsplash License

Share on Bluesky

In 2023, Masters swimmer Anne Coombes got excluded from swimming in the female category by Swim England. They still refuse to update her sex marker from male to female.

Swim England changed the rules and ignored advice

Anne has been a competitive swimmer all her life and a Masters swimmer since 1989. In 2020 she transitioned and received permission to compete as a female swimmer in 2022 after an arduous process of providing documentation.

She was part of the consultation when Swim England were deciding how to manage transgender swimmers. Anne said “I told them they didn’t have a problem, that they should leave things as they are and if a problem arises, then I would be the first in the line to help them sort it out.”

Unfortunately for Anne, Swim England dismissed her advice. She recalls her disappointment at being excluded:

“They did not take my advice and they rang me up to tell me of their change of rules on 1 September 2023. the new rules being that only people who were assigned female at birth could swim in the female category. The other category would be Open/Male and would take everybody else.”

Fear of being outed 

The rule change caused Anne to fear being outed as a trans woman. The diversity officer instructed her to wear a woman’s swim costume (due to breast growth). This along with her name being displayed on an electric scoreboard at national competitions would out her as trans to the other swimmers, judges and spectators. Anne said:

I’ll be stood there in the starting blocks wearing a female costume and all the people around me will be wearing [swim shorts].

When she brought up the fear of being outed to the diversity officer they “had no answer”.

A courageous protest 

In a courageous display of resistance Anne swam an event Topless to highlight the hypocrisy of the new rules.

Speaking to Pink News she said:

“I’m trying to show that this policy isn’t thought through, and it’s meant to hit trans people and nobody else.

There are many who say I should only compete against men because I have a man’s advantage, and that just isn’t the case.”

A recent meta-analysis study found no evidence that trans athletes are ‘a threat’ to women’s sports.

Refusal to update sex marker 

Speaking to North West Bylines Anne described in detail the unfairness of Swim England not allowing her to update her sex marker to female. She said:

“I made a Subject Access Request in the middle of last year. In their cover email they pointed out that they had recorded my sex as male. A  bit of background: when I enter a swimming competition, the people running the competition can access the Swim England database to check details about me. So, SE had me down as male so that the software that all clubs use placed me in the ‘correct’ category. The email implied that they could not change this. I complained to the ICO stating that they had had enough time to get their software sorted out (2 years), and that the upshot of this was that the results of swimming competitions were available to any member of the public where it clearly implied that I was male.”

Anne is hoping the ICO will respond to her complaint soon. She expected a response by the end of February (this year- 2026). No response has been given yet. 

Swimming with those of the same ability

Anne can’t understand why they won’t update her sex marker. She swims with those of the same ability as her’s. She is not stealing anything from other women. The competition is fair.

Anne describes it as:

I swim with people who are similar to me in terms of pace. We spur each other on because we are of similar ability. That is it. That is my race. I compete against people who are close to me in speed. The important bit is the competition, designed to be against people that are like each other. Now, the times we recorded are compared with people in the same age group.

I cannot emphasise enough that I swim against people who have the same ability. That is what I enjoy, that is what helps us all swim faster. The reason I emphasise this is to negate the TERF argument that I am in to win it.

A backlash for any woman deemed not feminine enough

TERFs frequently use sport as a vehicle to unfairly discriminate against trans women. It is not about fairness in sport. It is about excluding those they don’t deem “woman enough”.

Algerian boxer Imane Khelif suffered horrendous abuse after winning a gold medal at the 2024 Paris Olympics. People accused her of being a “man” despite being born a woman. Khelif hit back at the bullies in an interview with CNN. Khelif said:

I’m a woman. I want to live my life… Please do not exploit me in your political agendas.

Political agendas are precisely what they are. A political campaign of intolerance and hate against trans people.

In 2024 Exeter UK, Assigned Media reported:

A half-marathon win by a mother-of-four in Exeter, UK is demonstrating in stark terms how much the anti-trans hate campaign has done for women in athletics. Anna Harrold’s victory at the Great West Race was met by slurs, harassment, and false claims that she was a trans woman, according to reporting in the Independent. Harold later told the Independent that no one should be subjected to such monstrous treatment.



Swim England comment:

We contacted Swim England for a comment or explanation.

This was their repy:

“Thank you for your email.

We don’t comment on individual cases and you can find our Transgender and Non-binary Competition policy here: Swim England Transgender and Non-binary Competition policy – Swim England.”


a pink and a blue lollipop, both heartshape
Equality

Defining sex – why it’s not as simple as you might think

by Jennie Kermode
10 June 2024 - Updated on 4 March 2026
    Great read!  Let me buy you a coffee.

Friends of Bylines Network

There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.

STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.

BECOME A FRIEND
Tags: trans
Previous Post

Blackburn cathedral – 100 years of serving a community

Next Post

Earth’s Follies: Week 56 – Crab feasts, cabinet clown shoes and the Great Badger banknote panic

Sophie Molly

Sophie Molly

Sophie Molly is a human rights campaigner and journalist from Aberdeen. She writes about social justice and issues that affect people's daily lives. She believes in equity, freedom and the protection of human rights. She works hard to get the voices of marginalised communities heard. In 2024 Sophie stood as an Independent Candidate in the UK General Election. Follow Sophie on BlueSky

Related Posts

Famil sits on grassy field. Parents and three children
Equality

Scrapping the two-child limit lifts children out of poverty

by North West Bylines Reports
17 November 2026
man addresses room full of people
Opinion Corner

How long should Lord Khan remain London Mayor?

by Cleisthenes' Disciple
13 November 2026
Queer Youth Summit: People sit in auditorium and watch a screen that says LGBT+ Youth Summit
Equality

The Proud Trust is getting ready for the 2027 Queer Youth Summit

by The Prominence Collective
9 November 2026
computer code in different colours on a black background
NHS

Palantir and the NHS – a critique

by Les Jones
4 November 2026
hand holding a mobile phone showing social media widgets
Greater Manchester

Do my councillor’s words represent me?

by Anna Schurer
4 November 2026
Next Post
Xylb'tok, a multi-limbed, three-eyed knobbly pink Martian with his tree feet wearing shiny black Oxford shoes, stands examining a 5 Lunars banknote with a picture of a wild Lunar haggis, a dun-coloured furry creature, on it. On teh ground lies another crumpled note, featuring a penguin. From the fourth shoe emerges Grzzl'x, a spiky, three-eyed white Martian felinoid, coiled around the pole of a banner. Blye text on the white banner says '#FreeLarry'. Another banner, black, is propped up on the ground, the text in white letters says 'Ban XL Bullies'.

Earth’s Follies: Week 56 – Crab feasts, cabinet clown shoes and the Great Badger banknote panic

SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

A day in my shoes AI by-election Charity Christmas coal mine Conservatives Coronation Cost of living Democracy Energy Eurovision EU support farming Festival Finance Gaza Homeless housing HS2 Labour Levelling up Liberal Democrats Long Read mayoral election minneapolis NI Protocol obesity poetry Poverty press release Press Releases recycle Reform Reviews riots Russia Satire SEND Sewage trans Ukraine water women xylb'tok
North West Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North West and beyond.

North West Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2022-2026 North West Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9755

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Crime and Justice
    • Education
    • Equality
    • Health
    • Migration
    • War
    • World
  • Politics
    • Brexit
    • Economy
    • Opinion
  • Environment
    • Nature and Wildlife
    • Pollution
  • Lifestyle
    • Art, Craft and Photography
    • Books
    • Culture, Language and Religion
    • Dance
    • Food and Drink
    • History
    • Music
    • Sport
    • TV, Film and Theatre
  • Business
    • Local Business
    • Technology
    • Trade
    • Transport
  • Region
    • Cheshire
    • Cumbria
    • Greater Manchester
    • Lancashire
    • Liverpool and Merseyside
    • Local Councils and Elections
  • Cartoon
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2022-2026 North West Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9755