Mancunian Paul Carroll’s Shaking Hands With Elvis explores a Britain where the government has sold off the NHS and legalised assisted dying. When people are no longer deemed useful to the state, or can’t afford their medical bills, the state offers an incentive to those wanting to take the final step. But could it go too far?
The story
In Carroll’s book, the NHS no longer exists and euthanasia is commercialised, with the government promoting assisted dying schemes as a way to reduce the number of adults not actively working and paying taxes.
Be they elderly, seriously ill and unable to pay for their own healthcare, unable to work, imprisoned, or just tired of life, the idea of stepping out of life is actively encouraged by the fictitious government. It saves the state money, and the people don’t have to worry about being a burden or in pain. Sell off your assets, pay for your luxury week at the clinic with a gentle end, and the government adds a little bonus to what is left of your money for your heirs.
The scheme seems to take off, with an unscrupulous clinic owner and a government minister plotting to enlarge their target demographic. But some people don’t agree with the setup. And when a group of strangers already booked into the clinic where they will meet their end have second thoughts and join forces, events spiral out of control.
Assisted dying: not a novel concept
Assisted dying is not a new concept in popular culture. It has been the subject of several futuristic films, in times when the whole concept seemed very unlikely to ever become reality. Death Race 2000 (1975), for example, is set in a futuristic America where, once a year, old and infirm people are placed on the road and competing drivers hit as many as they can, getting points for those hits. A 1991 episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation portrays an alien planet with humanoid lifeforms who commit suicide when they reach the age of 60 so as to leave the planet’s dwindling resources for the younger, more productive generation.
Today, some countries’ legislations allow assisted dying – but under strict rules. Even still, problematic or questionable practices may arise. An example of this is the “Drug X” scandal in the Netherlands. In this case, a man was convicted for illegally selling a “suicide drug” over the internet to people who didn’t qualify for euthanasia under Dutch law. The court found that the product didn’t give the painless death it promised, and said that it “undermined the carefully formulated Dutch euthanasia law.”
Many religions are adamantly against assisted dying, as they consider all life sacred – taking a life, be it someone else’s or your own, is against their teaching. On the other hand, organisations that care for seriously or terminally ill people – or people who are chronically ill themselves – tend to have mixed opinions. Should human life be preserved at all costs and until the bitter end, even if there is no hope of improvement?
And who decides whether there is hope, especially when those involved are in emotional or mental distress? Situations may change, and new medications may offer hope where there wasn’t any before. As the decision is final, it should be taken without any coercion, and preferably without commercial gain for anyone.
There are many voices and opinions on the subject, and many sides to the dice. Carroll describes his main characters and their situations with sympathy and sensitivity, and you can’t help but hope they all find an option other than to end life prematurely.
Could it happen here?
This is a fictional tale of a turn of events that seems terrifying but compared to 30-50 years ago it feels less unlikely than it did then. The NHS is being sold off bit by bit, and social care is being underfunded. Prisons are overcrowded and our government is making noises that the state pension of the past may be unsustainable. Let’s hope this fiction doesn’t turn out to be within the realm of terrifying possibility.
Shaking Hands With Elvis by Paul Carrol. 276 pages, due out 1 March 2024.







